Seceding From the States?

Question by jpc8015: Seceding from the States?
Did anybody hear about the Lakota Indian Tribe wanting to disolve their treaties with the federal government and set up their own country? Is this a good idea for them? How would they manage without federal aid for everything from “cultural centers” to drug and alcohol rehabilitation? At some point would we need to go and forcibly take their land back from them in order to save them from themselves? What would the consequences be, could we then take away their status as a soveirgn nation and not give them treaties?

Best answer:

Answer by Perplexed Bob
Well, considering the living conditions on reservations, I don’t see how they were be losing much if they declared their own country.

What do you think? Answer below!



Drug Rehabilitation Center Asheville NC Call (828) 348-8433 –, We are your Drug Rehabilitation Center in Asheville NC. Call Us Today at (828) 348-8433 or Visit: Mountain Treatment Center 260 Merrimon Avenue Asheville, NC 28801 (828) 348-8433 US Mountain Treatment Center provides Asheville consumers the best drug rehabilitation center products and services. Our experts specializes in rehab counseling, addiction center, alcohol detox. Mountain Treatment Center has developed into Asheville NC’s drug rehabilitation center Business leader. Our outstanding consumer service personnel is looking forward to helping you. For additional information get in touch with us at: (828) 348-8433


Arturo C. Taca, Jr., MD, FABPN, INSynergy Treatment Center Founder, Selected

Filed under: drug rehabilitation center

Dr. Taca, a psychiatrist based in St. Louis, has a private practice since 2006 and recently launched INSynergy Treatment Center, a premier alcohol and drug rehabilitation facility serving patients throughout the Midwest. Prior to founding INSynergy in …


Austin Recovery and St. David's Foundation Continue Partnership to Help

Filed under: drug rehabilitation center

Austin Recovery, the largest and most affordable not-for-profit drug and alcohol treatment center in Texas, has been awarded a grant from the St. David's Foundation for the fifth consecutive year. The grant provides Austin Recovery $ 356100 to support …
Read more on MarketWatch (press release)


Heroin use on the rise in suburban areas

Filed under: drug rehabilitation center

With addicts desperate for a cheaper high than prescription drugs or seeking a more powerful fix, experts are seeing heroin addiction treatment admissions, overdoses and fatalities rising in nearly every region, including areas where the drug has …
Read more on WXYZ


More drug rehabilitation center Resources

Seceding from the States? Pictures

Federal Government against the seceding States was in disregard of the limitations of the Constitution, and destructive of the principles of the Declaration of Independence.8 … Fetch Doc

Seceding from the States? Photos

Confederate Confiscations: A Digital Exhibit
(and subsequently other seceding states’ officials) acted quickly to confiscate federal property in the state. Influenced by secession sympathizers in his cabinet, Lincoln’s … Fetch Full Source

Seceding from the States?

T F Lincoln successfully prevented any more states from seceding after his inauguration, 2. T F In order to appease the Border States, Lincoln first insisted that the North was fighting … Read More

Seceding from the States? Images

The Civil War – Create A Living Timeline Overview
Surrender southern federal forts to the seceding states, southern state troops seized them. At Fort Sumter, South Carolina troops repulsed a supply ship trying to reach federal forces based in the fort. … Access Document

Photos of Seceding from the States?

Chapter 15 Toward Civil War (1840-1861)
Do What would happen in the slave states of Virginia, North Carolina, Kentucky, Tennessee, Missouri, and Arkansas If the US used force against the Confederate States, the remaining slave states might secede Lincoln Takes Office Continued In his Inaugural Address, Lincoln spoke to the seceding states … Get Doc

Photos of Seceding from the States?

NH Senator Lobbies For Refugee To Run In Olympics
FILE – In this 2008 file photo, Iowa State's Guor Marial (175) competes against Colorado's Jordan Kyle (162) and Texas A& M's Shadrack Songok (268) during the Big 12 cross country meet at Iowa State's Cross Country Course in Ames, Iowa. Marial attended high school in Concord, N.H., after fleeing his war-torn birth country. … Read News

Seceding from the States? Pictures

The United States, etc., etc., had been granted amnesty. Immediately thereafter, each of the seceding States functioned as regular States in the Union with both State and Federal Courts in … Retrieve Document

Seceding from the States? Pictures

PowerPoint Presentation
The Politics of Reconstruction The process by which the seceding states are restored to a proper relationship with the Union. Republican Myth – “Since there was no legal secession, there need be no readmission.” … Read Full Source

Seceding from the States? Images

Five Myths About Why The South seceded By James W. Loewen …
The South seceded over states' rights. Confederate states did claim the right to secede, but no state claimed to be seceding for that right. In fact, Confederates opposed states' rights — that is, the right of Northern states not to support slavery. … Doc Retrieval

Seceding from the States?

Resource C Timeline From The Election Of 1860 To Death In 1865
These eleven states eventually formed the Confederate States of America. • Why did the south secede after Lincoln became president? February 1861 ­­ The South Creates a Government. At a convention in Montgomery, Alabama, the seven seceding states created the Confederate … Fetch This Document

Seceding from the States?

Secession Fever
And generously funded by JPMorgan Chase & Co., highlights the seizure of federal assets by seceding states and the massive financial strain this created for the U.S. … Retrieve Content

Pictures of Seceding from the States?

Chapter 10 Section 4
Virginia- union slave state, proposed a peace conference No one came from the secession states A final attempt 21 States attend a peace conference to try and find a solution. The seceding states met in Montgomery, Alabama and declared themselves the Confederate States of America or the Confederacy. … Doc Retrieval

Pictures of Seceding from the States?

The Creation Of States In International Law
(3) Military and civil aid to seceding regimes 421 (4) Problems of continuity and commencement 421 States is regulated by international law, and is not simply a ‘matter of fact ’. … Fetch This Document

Pictures of Seceding from the States?

The Civil War 1861-1865
Realizing that they needed to form some sort of central government, delegates from the seceding states met in Montgomery, Alabama, in February 1861. … Get Content Here

Images of Seceding from the States?

NH Senator Lobbies For Refugee To Run In Olympics
When he was 8 years old, Guor Marial ran under cover of night to escape child slavery in a labor camp in Sudan. … Read News

Seceding from the States? Images

Chapter 20 Girding For War: The North And The South, 1861-1865
Lincoln successfully prevented any more states from seceding after his inauguration. ___ 2. In order to appease the Border States, Lincoln first insisted that the North was fighting … Visit Document

Seceding from the States? Images

Ch. 10 Sectional Conflict Intensifies
Delegates from the seceding states met in Montgomery, Alabama and declared themselves to be a new nation, the Confederate States of America or the Confederacy. … Retrieve Document

From Twitter:

Register Your Colleagues In Drug Rehabilitation Center’s Program To Attain Recovery – by Annie_Pet (Annie Peterson)


5 Responses to Seceding From the States?

  • Fancy That says:

    technically, all Native tribes are considered their own nation. So the US has many nations with in the nation.

    I think we’ve done quite enough ‘forcibly taking their land’. And you cannot take back what you never had a right to in the first place. That property belonged to these people long before we came along.

    It is the right of any group to define their culture, as long as it doesn’t pick my pocket or break my leg.

  • Amy says:

    That’s fine; they can do it if they want, but if the land they’re sitting on belongs to the United States government, then they’re going to have to leave or be jailed for trespassing.

    Most people don’t really understand this, but the land that is designated for each state in this country belongs to the U.S. government, not to the individual state. So if, for instance, a state happened to want to secede from the union and wanted to retain its land, it would have to go to war with the U.S. military in order to do that. Not so easy.

    Now picture an Indian tribe fighting our army.

    So it’s unlikely it’ll happen.

  • Big Jon says:

    If the federal government balked at allowing the southern states of the Confederacy to secede from the Union, what in the world makes the Lakota think that the government would allow them to declare their land a separate country from the U.S.?

    I don’t think they have the means to do so by force, which is what it would take.

    And you said it yourself – they wouldn’t be able to manage their daily living without the federal aid they receive now. The current treaties we hold with the Lakota Sioux may call them a “sovereign nation”, but their economic status hardly makes that true, and their land lies within another sovereign state that might turn their National Guard units on them if they get too noisy.

  • Rev Ron says:

    Folks, the Lakota People within the Sioux Nation have disacknowledged all treaties with the United States government and are seceding and proclaiming themselves an independent nation. They have also declared the northern Great Plains a place for wild bison without cattle and their accompanying fences and are talking about bringing Yellowstone’s besieged wild bison herds to this region for good. This is not a rumor; Putin has even chimed in on the side of the Lakota!

  • Mentat says:

    I understand we took their land and all, but the US has spoiled them, badly, to make up for it. I don’t know if this particular tribe is like the others, but being by itself would be a truly tough trial.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *